All field notes

How-to ·

Account executive skills that show up on the deal

The account executive skills that win deals: discovery, quantifying the problem, multi-threading, the business case and closing. How to see and build each.

The account executive skills that win deals are running a first meeting, discovery, quantifying the problem, reaching the people who decide, building the business case, negotiating and closing. Each one shows up at a specific point in the deal.

Most lists of AE skills read like a job advert: communication, resilience, time management, product knowledge. They are true of any good employee and they do not help a manager decide what to coach. The list below follows a deal from first meeting to signature and names what each skill looks like on a call, so you can tell whether a rep has it.

What an account executive's job is

An account executive owns new-business deals from the first qualified meeting to the signed contract. They run discovery, work the buying committee, build the case for change and negotiate the deal to close.

A typical mid-market or enterprise AE runs fifteen to forty open deals at a time, with cycles from a few weeks to most of a year. They are usually measured on new revenue against a quarterly or annual quota. Their manager coaches them in one-on-ones and deal reviews, and enablement trains them through onboarding and certification.

The skills below are the ones the deal tests. Some AEs have most of them on day one; most new AEs ramp over two to three quarters. Our guide to how to ramp an account executive covers the first months.

The skills, in deal order

Each skill is described by what it looks like on a call when the rep has it.

Where each AE skill shows on a deal
  1. 01First meetingEarns a second one with a reason
  2. 02DiscoveryFinds the problem and puts a number on it
  3. 03Multi-threadingReaches the people who decide
  4. 04Business caseIn the buyer's measures, checked with them
  5. 05Negotiation and closeTrades, holds value, agrees the date

1. Running a first meeting. The rep opens with a reason the meeting is worth the buyer's time, gets the buyer talking about their situation within the first few minutes, and ends with a second meeting booked for a reason the buyer agreed to.

2. Discovery. The rep finds the buyer's problem, how it shows up in their work, and what has been tried already. They ask follow-up questions on the buyer's answers and summarize back what they heard.

3. Quantifying the problem. The rep gets a number: what the problem costs in time, money or risk, in a measure the buyer's leadership tracks. This is the skill most often missing, and the one the rest of the deal depends on.

4. Multi-threading. The rep reaches the people who will decide, beyond the first contact. They ask early who else will weigh in, and get at least one of those people onto a call.

5. Building the business case. The rep turns the quantified problem into a case for change in the buyer's own measures, checks it with the buyer, and helps the champion present it internally.

6. Negotiating. The rep trades: any change in price comes with a change in scope, term or timing. They hold the value the business case established.

7. Closing. The rep agrees a decision date tied to something on the buyer's side, maps the steps to signature with the buyer, and keeps the deal moving through procurement and legal.

Product knowledge and pipeline discipline matter too. They support these skills, and gaps in them tend to show up as gaps in the seven above.

How to build the skills, step by step

The steps below are for a manager building these skills across a team of AEs. They take about a quarter to run once, and repeat after that.

1. Assess each rep on real calls

Listen to three calls per rep from the last quarter, chosen across the deal stages. Mark each skill on a simple scale, with the moment in the call that justifies the mark. Our guide on how to assess sales competencies covers writing levels you can mark.

2. Pick one skill per rep

Choose the one skill that is lowest and costs the rep the most deals. For many AEs that is quantifying the problem or multi-threading. One skill a quarter is enough. Five at once produces none.

3. Coach it on live deals

Use the rep's own deals to work on the skill. In each deal review, ask about the skill first: what number did the buyer give, who else has been on a call. Plan the next conversation together, including the question the rep will ask.

4. Rehearse before the calls that matter

Before a call where the skill will be tested, have the rep say the key part out loud. For quantifying the problem, that is the follow-up question after the buyer says "a lot". Rehearsal finds the stumble before the buyer hears it.

5. Debrief after the call

After the call, ask what the buyer said when the rep tried the skill. Debrief the same day while the rep remembers the words.

6. Check transfer at the end of the quarter

Mark three new calls per rep on the same scale. Did the skill move? If it did, pick the next one. If it did not, change the way it is coached before adding more sessions. In a study of 1,246 pharmaceutical sales reps, managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment, and frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results (Dahling et al. 2016, via our Game Winning Kickoffs field study).

A worked example

This example is illustrative. Priya joined Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm, as an account executive two quarters ago. She sells freight management to manufacturers and is at 70% of her ramp target.

Assessment. Her manager listens to three of her calls. Her first meetings are strong: buyers talk freely and she books second meetings. Her discovery is good. Her quantifying is weak: on two calls the buyer describes late shipments, and Priya moves on without asking what they cost. Her deals stall at the business case because there is no number to build it on.

One skill. Her manager picks quantifying the problem.

On live deals. In each weekly deal review, the first question is "what number did the buyer give you?". On a deal with a mid-sized packaging maker, Priya has none. They plan the question for her next call: "When a shipment is late, what happens on the plant floor, and what does that cost you in overtime?".

Rehearse and debrief. Priya says the question out loud twice before the call. On the call, the plant manager estimates the overtime at a figure he says he reports monthly. In the debrief, her manager asks whether she confirmed it back. She did not; it goes into the next call plan.

Transfer. At the end of the quarter, two of her three new calls have a number from the buyer. Her manager moves the focus to multi-threading.

Where it goes wrong

Coaching traits. "Be more confident" and "build better rapport" do not tell a rep what to do on the next call. Name the behavior on the call.

Training the skill once. A workshop on discovery, with no coaching on live deals afterwards, rarely shows up on calls. Research on training transfer finds that what happens back at work is more strongly tied to whether a skill gets used than what happens in the training room (Saks and Belcourt 2006).

Skipping the number. Many AEs are good at discovery and stop before the number. Without it, the business case and the negotiation are both weaker. Check for it on every deal.

Judging skills by results alone. A rep can hit quota on two large inbound deals with weak skills, or miss with strong ones on a bad patch. Look at the calls.

Coaching AEs on every deal

A manager with eight AEs, each with twenty deals, cannot review every deal every week. The skill gets coached on the two or three deals that reach the one-on-one, and the rest go unreviewed.

On Replicate Labs, an AE can start a call with Caty in one click and talk through any deal in the team's own method, by voice or video. Caty stages it by buyer evidence, names what is missing and plans the next conversation with them. Typing is the fallback. Managers see which deals carry buyer evidence in Bryce's Monday read. More on the AE's coaching week is in sales coaching for account executives, the loop behind it is in our sales coaching framework, and for reps shows how it works from the rep's side. To set it up for your AEs, talk to us.

FAQ

What skills does an account executive need?

An account executive needs to run a first meeting, run discovery, quantify the problem, reach the people who decide, build a business case, negotiate and close. Each one shows up at a specific stage of the deal.

What is the most important skill for an account executive?

Quantifying the problem is often the most important AE skill, because the business case, the negotiation and the close all depend on a number the buyer agreed to. It is also the one most often missing.

How do you improve account executive skills?

Improve AE skills by assessing them on real calls, picking one skill per quarter, coaching it on the rep's live deals, rehearsing before key calls and checking whether it moved on new calls.

How long does it take a new account executive to ramp?

Most new account executives take two to three quarters to reach full productivity, depending on deal size and cycle length. Coaching on live deals from the first weeks shortens it.

What is the difference between an account executive and an account manager?

An account executive wins new business, from first meeting to signed contract. An account manager grows and renews existing customers after the first deal closes.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us