All field notes

Comparison ·

Deal coaching vs skill coaching: what each one fixes, and how to run both in one session

Deal coaching works one live opportunity; skill coaching builds one capability across many calls. When each fits, how to split a 1:1, and an example.

Deal coaching suits a manager with a live opportunity that needs a next move this week. Skill coaching suits a rep whose calls keep showing the same weakness. Most one-on-ones need both, in that order.

The two get set against each other as if a manager has to pick a side. In practice they answer different questions on different clocks, and the best sessions use the first to feed the second.

What deal coaching is

Deal coaching is a manager and a rep working one live opportunity to find what it is missing and agree the next conversation with the buyer. The output is a move the rep makes within days.

A deal coaching session starts from the deal. The rep talks through what the buyer has said and done, and the manager asks for the evidence behind each claim: who said the problem costs money, how much, who else has to agree, what the last call ended with. The session ends with one gap named and one opening line for the next call. Our deal coaching guide covers the full method, and the glossary entry on deal coaching gives the short version.

Its strength is speed. A good session changes what happens on Tuesday's call. Its weakness is that it can fix the same mistake on ten deals in a row without the rep ever seeing the pattern.

What skill coaching is

Skill coaching develops one selling capability, such as discovery or gaining commitment, across many of a rep's calls until it shows up without prompting. The output is a change in how the rep sells, visible over weeks.

A skill coaching plan starts from the rep. The manager looks across several calls, picks the weakest skill that matters at the rep's stage, describes what the next level sounds like, and holds that one skill for several weeks. Each week the rep plans how to use it on a real call, uses it, and debriefs it. The glossary entry on skill coaching sets out those steps.

Its strength is that it compounds. A rep who learns to put a number on the buyer's problem does it on every deal after. Its weakness is distance from the quarter: a manager with a forecast due on Friday rarely spends the hour on a skill plan.

How they differ, on the things a manager decides

The two differ on scope, time, evidence and who gets better.

Decision Deal coaching Skill coaching
Starting point One open opportunity One rep's pattern across calls
Question it answers What does this deal need from the buyer next? What does this rep need to do better on every call?
Evidence used What this buyer said and did Several calls scored on the team's scorecard
Time to a result Days, on the next buyer call Weeks, across many calls
Output One move and an opening line One skill, a described target level, weekly practice
Who gets better The deal, then the rep a little The rep, then every deal they touch
Common failure Turns into an inspection of stage and close date Turns into a training module with no live deal attached
Best owner The rep's manager, close to the deal The manager, with enablement supplying the scorecard

Two rows matter most. The evidence row tells a manager which material to bring to the session. The failure row explains why each kind goes wrong: deal coaching slides into forecast questions, and skill coaching drifts away from real buyers.

Why the split is less clean than it looks

Most skill problems show up first as deal problems. A rep who never reaches the economic buyer will have a deal stall at the same point, again and again, and each stall looks like bad luck until someone lines up three of them.

That is the argument for running skill coaching through live deals. The research supports it. Across 117 studies, skills held or grew when people trained on their own scenarios with trained managers behind them (Taylor, Russ-Eft and Chan 2005). Transfer studies find that what happens back at work is more strongly tied to whether a skill gets used than what happens in the training room (Saks and Belcourt 2006; Blume et al. 2010). Both are summarized in our kickoff field study.

A further finding shapes how managers should coach. Across 1,246 pharmaceutical reps, managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment, and frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results (Dahling et al. 2016). The practical reading for a manager is to work on the quality of the questions in each session before adding more sessions to the calendar.

How to choose for a given deal

Choose by two things: how much is at stake on the deal right now, and how large the rep's skill gap is. Plot the deal on those two and the right kind of coaching follows.

Which kind of coaching a deal calls for
A lot at stakeLittle at stake
Deal coachingFind the gap, plan the next call
Deal coaching that carries a skillFix the deal and name the pattern
Leave it with the repA quick check in the next 1:1
Skill coachingPractice it, then use it on the next deal
Small skill gapLarge skill gap
  • A lot at stake, small skill gap. Run deal coaching. The rep knows how to sell; this deal has a specific hole. Find it and plan the next call.
  • A lot at stake, large skill gap. Run deal coaching that carries a skill. Fix the deal first, then name the pattern out loud: "This is the third deal where finance appeared late. Let's work on that for the next month."
  • Little at stake, small skill gap. Leave it with the rep and check it quickly in the next one-on-one.
  • Little at stake, large skill gap. Run skill coaching. Use practice or a lower-stakes deal to build the skill before it meets a large one.

The second case is the one most teams under-use. It is where a deal session produces two outputs, the move for this deal and the skill for the month, and it costs no extra meeting.

Running both in one 30-minute session

A manager can run both kinds in one weekly session by giving deal coaching the first twenty minutes and the skill the last ten. The order matters, because the deal supplies the evidence for the skill.

  1. Minutes 0 to 5: the rep tells the deal. From the buyer's side, uninterrupted.
  2. Minutes 5 to 15: evidence check. The manager asks for the buyer's words behind each claim and finds the first gap.
  3. Minutes 15 to 20: plan the next conversation. One move, one opening line, rehearsed out loud.
  4. Minutes 20 to 27: name the skill. If the gap matches the rep's current skill focus, say so and connect it. If it is new, note it and look for it in the next two deals.
  5. Minutes 27 to 30: commit. The date of the buyer call, and what the rep will try that belongs to the skill.

The steps follow the structure of a deal review, with a skill check added at the end.

An example

This example is illustrative. A rep at Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm, brings a stalled $90,000 deal to her one-on-one. The operations director likes the proposal, the close date has moved once, and nobody from finance has been on a call.

The manager runs the deal part first. The evidence check finds the gap: the operations director has never said what late deliveries cost per month, so finance has no number to approve. The planned move is a short call with the director to agree that number, ending with a request for twenty minutes with the finance lead. The rep rehearses the opening line twice.

Then the manager runs the skill part. He pulls up her last two lost deals. Both stalled at finance, and in both, the problem was never put in money. The skill for the next month is quantifying the problem on discovery calls. Each week she will plan one cost question before a call and debrief what the buyer said.

Four weeks later, she brings a new deal where the buyer named a monthly cost on the first call. The deal session that week is shorter, because the gap it would have found is already closed.

Where an AI sales expert fits

An AI sales expert can run the deal part on any day the rep needs it, which frees the manager's time for the skill. With Replicate Labs, a rep can start a call with Caty in one click and talk the deal through by voice or video, in the team's own method, with typing as the fallback. Caty remembers the agreed move and asks about it next time.

Managers get a read across the team from Bryce, including which deals carry buyer evidence, which shows where the same gap keeps appearing. That pattern is where a skill plan starts. Talk to us to try it on a deal of your own.

FAQ

What is the difference between deal coaching and skill coaching?

Deal coaching works one live opportunity to find its next move with the buyer. Skill coaching develops one selling capability across many calls until the rep uses it without prompting.

Which is more important, deal coaching or skill coaching?

Each fixes a different problem, so a team needs both. Deal coaching protects this quarter's deals, while skill coaching changes how a rep sells every deal after it.

How much time should a manager spend on deal coaching versus skill coaching?

A common split is twenty minutes on a live deal and ten on the rep's current skill in each weekly one-on-one. Shift the balance toward skills for new reps.

Can you do skill coaching on a live deal?

Skill coaching works best on live deals, because the rep uses the skill on a real buyer and debriefs what happened. Practice helps when the stakes on a deal are too high.

Who should run skill coaching, a manager or enablement?

The manager should run it, because skill coaching happens in weekly one-on-ones on real calls. Enablement supplies the scorecard, the target levels and practice material.

What is will coaching?

Will coaching addresses a rep's motivation or confidence, where skill coaching addresses ability. Many teams use the skill and will split to decide whether a rep needs teaching or encouragement.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us