All field notes

How-to ·

How to coach a rep who pushes back on feedback

To coach a defensive sales rep, find what the pushback is about, coach from the recording, let them assess it first, and agree one small change to test.

To coach a defensive sales rep, find out what the pushback is about, coach from the call recording, ask for their own read first, and agree one small change to test on a single call.

What the job is

Coaching a rep who pushes back means getting a change in their behavior on calls when your first attempts at feedback have met an argument, a shrug or silence. The goal is the change on the call. Winning the conversation in the 1:1 is beside the point, and a rep who concedes to end the meeting changes nothing.

Pushback is information. Reps resist feedback for a handful of reasons, and each one needs a different response:

  • They do not trust the source. They think the manager has not listened to the call, or has not sold in their segment.
  • They dispute the evidence. They remember the call differently, or think the moment was taken out of context.
  • They disagree with the standard. They think the behavior being asked for does not work with their buyers.
  • They feel judged. The feedback arrives as a verdict on them, often in front of others or near a pay review.
  • They are overloaded. They have been given six things to fix and are protecting themselves from all of them.

Some resistance is right. Trained experts marking the same sales calls disagree with each other on 18% of scores, according to our own research on call scoring. If your feedback is a judgment call, a rep who disagrees may have a point. Coaching works better when both of you are looking at the same evidence against a standard you both accept.

Who does it and how long it takes

The front-line manager does this work, in the regular 1:1 or a dedicated coaching session. Expect it to take three to six weeks of weekly sessions to move from pushback to a change the rep owns. If a second-line leader or enablement lead is involved, they support the manager and stay out of the room unless invited.

The learning research supports patience over pressure. A study of 1,246 pharmaceutical reps (Dahling and colleagues, 2016) found that managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment, and that frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results. More sessions of the same feedback will not move a defensive rep. Better sessions might.

How to coach a defensive rep in seven steps

  1. Ask what the pushback is about. Before the next session, ask the rep directly: "Last time it felt like the feedback did not land. What was off about it?" Listen for which of the five causes above it is. Do not argue with the answer. Write it down.
  2. Agree the standard first. Get agreement on what good looks like before discussing their call. Use the team's method or scorecard, in writing, with an example. "On a discovery call, the buyer puts a number on the problem before we demo." If the rep disagrees with the standard, have that conversation separately. It is a fair conversation to have.
  3. Coach from the recording. Play the moment from the call together. The buyer's own words settle most disputes about what happened, and the manager's summary of a call is easy to argue with. If you were not on the call and have not listened to it, do that first. A rep can tell.
  4. Ask for their read first. Before you say anything, ask: "What do you hear in that moment?" Defensive reps often name the problem themselves once they hear it, and a problem the rep named is much easier to work on than one the manager named.
  5. Pick one change, and make it small. One behavior, on one type of call. "Next time a buyer says a problem costs them a lot, ask roughly how much last quarter." A small change is easy to agree to and easy to check. Feedback on everything at once is what makes reps defensive in the first place.
  6. Frame it as a test. Agree to try the change on one specific call and then look at what happened together. The rep does not have to believe it will work. They only have to try it once. If it fails, you learn something about the standard.
  7. Follow up on the result. At the next session, start with that call. If the change worked, say so with the specific moment. If it did not, look at why together. If the rep refused to try it, that is a different conversation, about the job and expectations, and it belongs in a clearly labeled performance discussion.

Saks and Belcourt (2006) and Blume and colleagues (2010) found that what happens back at work is more strongly tied to whether a skill gets used than what happens in the training room. Step 7 is where the rep finds out whether the manager will notice.

From pushback to a change on the next call
  1. 01Find the causeTrust, the evidence, or the standard
  2. 02Agree the standardWhat good looks like, in writing
  3. 03Play the callThe buyer's own words, played back
  4. 04Rep assesses firstTheir read before yours
  5. 05Test one changeOne call, then look together

For the general method of giving feedback, see how to give sales feedback.

A worked example

This example is illustrative. Jordan is a senior account executive at Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. Jordan hits about 80% of quota and has done for three quarters. Every time the manager raises discovery, Jordan says the buyers in their territory hate being asked about numbers and just want to see the product.

The manager asks Jordan what is off about the feedback. Jordan says the manager has never sold to freight brokers and keeps quoting a playbook written for retail buyers. That is a dispute about the standard, and partly about trust.

So the manager changes the approach. They agree to listen to two of Jordan's recent calls together, one won and one lost, and to look only at what the buyer said in the first ten minutes. On the won call, the buyer volunteers that a missed pickup cost them a customer. On the lost call, the buyer mentions delays twice and Jordan moves straight to the demo.

The manager asks Jordan what is different between the two. Jordan says the won buyer told them what was at stake. The manager asks whether there was a moment on the lost call to ask the same thing. Jordan points to it.

They agree one test: on the next freight broker call, when a buyer mentions a delay, Jordan asks what the delay cost them. One call. They will listen to it together next week. A week later, Jordan reports that the buyer gave a number and the follow-up meeting is booked. The manager names the moment and asks Jordan to try it on the next two calls.

Where it goes wrong

  • Arguing about the summary. If the conversation is about what you think happened, the rep can always remember it differently. Play the recording.
  • Saving it all up. Feedback held for a quarterly review arrives as a verdict. Weekly, small and specific is easier to hear.
  • Feedback in public. Correcting a rep on a team call or in a group deal review makes almost anyone defensive. Keep corrections in the 1:1.
  • Treating all pushback as attitude. Sometimes the rep is right about their buyers. Look at the evidence before you decide.
  • Mixing coaching and performance management. A rep who thinks every coaching session is building a file will defend every point. If it has become a performance issue, say so clearly and separately.

For a rep who is also behind on numbers, see how to coach underperforming sales reps, and for the structure around these sessions, the sales coaching framework.

Where an AI sales expert helps

Some reps find it easier to hear feedback first from somewhere other than their manager. An AI sales expert can score a call against the team's own method and point at the moments, which gives the rep and manager the same evidence to discuss. Reps can also talk a live deal through by voice or video on a call before the 1:1, and arrive having already found the moment. Bryce works with managers on the 1:1 and the forecast. To see how it would fit your team, talk to us.

FAQ

How do you coach a defensive employee in sales?

Coach a defensive sales rep by finding out what the pushback is about, then coaching from the call recording with the rep giving their read first. Agree one small change and test it on a single call.

Why do some sales reps resist feedback?

Sales reps usually resist feedback because they distrust the source, dispute the evidence, disagree with the standard, feel judged, or have been given too many things to fix at once. Each cause needs a different response.

What do you say to a rep who gets defensive about feedback?

Ask them what felt wrong about the feedback, and listen without arguing. Then suggest listening to the call together and ask what they hear in the moment before you give your view.

When does resisting coaching become a performance issue?

Resisting coaching becomes a performance issue when a rep refuses to try an agreed change and results are below expectations. At that point, have a separate, clearly labeled conversation about expectations for the role.

Should managers coach reps who push back or move on?

Managers should keep coaching reps who push back, as long as the rep engages with the evidence and will test changes. Some pushback is fair, and a rep who argues is often more engaged than one who says nothing.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us