All field notes

How-to ·

How to coach your top performers

To coach top performers, find the skill that limits their next level, coach it from their best and worst real calls, and stretch them with harder deals.

To coach top performers, find the one skill that limits their next level, coach it from their own best and worst calls, and stretch them with harder real deals. First ask what they want from the next year.

What coaching a top performer involves

Coaching a top performer means helping someone who already hits their number get to the next level of the job. The next level might be larger deals, a senior buyer, a new segment or a path into management. The work is different from fixing a gap. Nothing is broken, so the coaching has to find what would make the rep better at the job they want next.

Many managers skip it. Their time goes to reps who are behind, and the top rep gets a pat on the back and an empty calendar. That has a cost. A strong seller who stops learning gets bored, and a bored strong seller is easy for a competitor to hire.

There is a second reason to coach them. A top rep's calls are the best evidence a team has of what good looks like in its own market. Coaching them well produces material that helps everyone else.

Who does it and how long it takes

The front-line manager owns the coaching. A second-line leader, a senior peer or an enablement lead can help with specific skills, but the manager keeps the plan.

Plan for one development session of 45 to 60 minutes a month, plus short debriefs on the deals that matter. That is less frequent than coaching for a newer rep. Top performers do not need weekly check-ins on basics, and a weekly session with nothing new in it feels like supervision. What they need is depth when you do meet.

Skill matters more than the calendar here. A study of 1,246 pharmaceutical reps (Dahling and colleagues, 2016) found that managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment, and that frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results. With a top performer, a poorly prepared session costs more credibility than it earns.

How to coach a top performer in seven steps

  1. Ask what they want next. Start with their goal for the next 12 months: a promotion, a bigger patch, a named account, management. The answer decides which skills matter. A rep aiming at enterprise deals needs different coaching from one aiming at a team lead role.
  2. Pull their best and worst calls. Take five or six recent calls and put them in order from strongest to weakest. Putting calls in order shows what separates them in a way a score on each call can hide. Listen for the moment the best call pulled ahead: the question that got the buyer to put a cost on the problem, or the point where the rep named a next step and the buyer agreed to a date.
  3. Find what separates the best from the worst. Top performers are often inconsistent in one place. Maybe their discovery is sharp with operations buyers and thin with finance. Maybe they handle objections well until price comes up. The difference between their top call and their bottom call is where the coaching sits.
  4. Name the ceiling skill. Pick one skill that would limit them at the next level. Write it as a behavior on a call: "gets a finance buyer to agree the cost of the problem in their own numbers." Agree it with the rep. If they do not believe it matters, the plan will not survive the first busy week.
  5. Stretch them with real deals. Give them work that needs the skill: a harder account, a senior buyer, a deal in a segment they have not sold into. Practice helps in the session, and a short roleplay of a tough executive moment is useful. Most of the growth comes from live deals with something at stake.
  6. Have them teach it. Ask the top performer to walk the team through one of their best calls, and to explain why they did what they did. Explaining a skill forces a rep to understand it, and the team gets evidence from its own market. Keep it occasional so it does not turn into unpaid enablement work.
  7. Review monthly on the same skill. At each monthly session, look at new calls for the ceiling skill. When it holds across calls, pick the next one. Spaced practice over weeks holds skills better than one intensive push; across 63 studies, Donovan and Radosevich (1999) found spaced practice beat massed practice.

The sales coaching framework shows how these sessions sit alongside deal reviews and pipeline reviews across a month.

Coaching a top performer
  1. 01Ask what they want nextPromotion, bigger deals, a new segment
  2. 02Compare best and worst callsRank them, find what separates them
  3. 03Name the ceiling skillThe one thing that limits the next level
  4. 04Stretch with real dealsA harder account, a senior buyer
  5. 05Make them teachExplaining it sharpens it
  6. 06Review monthlySame skill, new evidence

A worked example

This example is illustrative. Priya is the top account executive at Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. She has hit her number for six quarters and wants to sell to larger shippers.

Her manager asks what she wants from the next year. She says enterprise accounts. He pulls six of her recent calls and ranks them. Her two best calls are with operations directors: she gets them talking about late deliveries, puts numbers on the cost, and books the next meeting. Her two weakest are with finance leads. She falls back on a feature walkthrough, and the calls end without a next step.

They agree the ceiling skill: getting a finance buyer to agree the cost of the problem in the buyer's own numbers. He gives her a stretch account where the finance director is the economic buyer. Before the first call, they practice the opening five minutes twice. After the call, she brings the recording to a short debrief and they listen to the moment the finance director asked about payback.

A month later, she presents her best operations call to the team, with a slide on the three questions she uses to get a buyer to quantify a problem. In the next monthly session, they look at two new finance calls. One holds. They keep the same skill for another month.

Where coaching top performers goes wrong

  • Leaving them alone. The most common mistake. "You're doing great, keep going" is not coaching, and top reps notice when their manager has stopped looking at their work.
  • Coaching the basics. Talking a six-quarter top performer through discovery questions they have used for years wastes their time and yours. Start from what separates their best and worst calls.
  • Treating them as free enablement. Asking a top rep to mentor every new hire and run every team session can take time from their own deals. Agree a limit.
  • Praising outcomes only. Saying "great quarter" teaches nothing. Point at the behavior in a specific call that made the deal work, so they can do it on purpose.
  • Changing what works. Some top performers have an unusual style that works. Coach the ceiling skill without trying to make them sell the way you did.

For reps at the other end of the curve, see how to coach underperforming sales reps, and for the general method, how to coach sales reps.

Where an AI sales expert helps

Ranking six calls and finding what separates them takes a manager most of an afternoon. An AI sales expert can score each call against the team's own method and put the moments side by side before the session, so the manager arrives with evidence. Bryce works with managers on the 1:1 and the forecast. When a top performer wants to rehearse a hard executive call on a live deal, they can talk it through with an expert by voice or video on a call. To see how that would work for your team, talk to us.

FAQ

How do you coach a high performer?

Coach a high performer by finding the one skill that would limit them at the next level and working on it from their own calls. Compare their best and worst calls, agree the skill, and give them real deals that stretch it.

How often should you coach top performers?

A monthly development session of 45 to 60 minutes works for most top performers, plus short debriefs on important deals. They need depth more than frequency, so prepare each session with real calls.

Why do top performers need coaching?

Top performers need coaching to keep growing toward the next level of the job, and because a strong seller who stops learning is easy for a competitor to hire. Their calls also show the team what good looks like.

What should you not do when coaching a top performer?

Avoid coaching basics they mastered years ago, praising results without naming the behavior behind them, and loading them with so much mentoring that their own deals suffer.

How do you keep a top sales performer engaged?

Keep a top sales performer engaged by connecting coaching to what they want next, such as bigger deals or a leadership path, and giving them stretch work with real stakes. Ask for their goals before you suggest any plan.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us