All field notes

How-to ·

Sales kickoff awards that reward the right behavior

Sales kickoff awards ideas sorted by what they reward: results, or the behavior behind them. Twelve categories, how to judge them, and an example ceremony.

Kickoff awards that reward the right behavior pair the usual results awards with a few judged on how a deal was won, such as discovery call of the year, scored on the recording.

Awards are one of the parts of a kickoff people remember. In our field study of public kickoff records, 25% of 4,057 LinkedIn posts about kickoffs mentioned awards, against 8% for skills training. That attention is the reason to choose them carefully: whatever gets applauded on stage is what the room learns the company values.

What kickoff awards are for, who decides and how long it takes

Kickoff awards recognize the people and teams behind last year's results, and they tell everyone else what the company wants more of. The sales leader owns the list, sales ops supplies the numbers, and managers or a small panel judge the categories that need judgment.

Set the categories and criteria about eight weeks before the event and publish them before nominations open. Judged awards need two to three weeks for nominations, recordings and a panel review. The ceremony itself usually runs thirty to sixty minutes, often at a dinner.

Recognition is a fine job for the agenda to do. Keep it labeled as recognition, and do not count it as part of the learning minutes.

Two questions that sort any award

Any award answers two questions: does it reward a result or the behavior behind it, and does it go to one rep or to a team? Most kickoff lists sit almost entirely in one corner, results for individuals.

What an award rewards
A teamOne rep
Region of the yearA team's number
Deal team of the yearHow a group won one deal
Top performerOne rep's number
Discovery call of the yearOne rep's call, judged on the recording
The resultThe behavior behind it

Results awards, like top performer or region of the year, are easy to judge from the numbers, and they matter: people who hit their number should hear it. Their weakness is that they tell the room who won and nothing about how. Behavior awards, like discovery call of the year or deal team of the year, are judged on evidence of how a deal was won. They give the room something to copy.

A useful list has both. A good mix is roughly two thirds results and one third behavior, with at least one behavior award tied to the one behavior the kickoff is built around.

Sales kickoff award ideas and categories

Award Rewards How to judge it
Top performer Result, one rep Attainment against quota
President's Club Result, one rep Annual target met
Region or team of the year Result, team Team attainment
Rookie of the year Result, one rep Time to first closed deal, or ramp attainment
Comeback of the year Result, one rep Second-half recovery against the first half
Biggest new logo Result, one rep or team Largest first contract
Discovery call of the year Behavior, one rep A recording judged against the year's behavior
Deal team of the year Behavior, team How a group won one deal, told with the evidence
Best multithreaded deal Behavior, one rep or team Number of buyer roles engaged, with what each said
Lost deal of the year Behavior, one rep The clearest loss review and what changed after it
Coach of the year Behavior, manager Reps' nominations, with examples of coaching on live deals
Customer result of the year Result, account team A result the customer stated in their own measures

Awards for managers

Most lists forget the managers. A coach of the year award, nominated by reps with a specific example of coaching on a live deal, tells managers that coaching counts. It also matters for results: across 1,246 pharma reps, managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment, and frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results (Dahling et al. 2016).

Awards for losing well

A lost deal of the year sounds odd and works well. It goes to the rep who wrote the clearest review of a loss and changed something because of it. It makes it safe to talk about losses, which is where most of next year's behavior comes from.

How to set up kickoff awards in seven steps

  1. Start from the year's behavior. Write the one behavior the kickoff serves, for example "every discovery call ends with the economic buyer named and a dated next step". At least one award is judged against it.
  2. Pick the results awards from the numbers you already track. Attainment, President's Club, team of the year and rookie of the year come straight from sales ops. Keep the list short.
  3. Add two to four behavior awards. Choose categories that show how deals were won. Each needs a piece of evidence: a recording, a deal story with buyer quotes, a loss review.
  4. Publish the criteria before nominations open. Write what the panel will look for in a sentence per award. Published criteria stop the award from going to the most popular person in the room.
  5. Collect evidence with each nomination. For a discovery call award, the nomination is the recording plus two lines on why it shows the behavior. For deal team of the year, it is the deal told from the buyer's side.
  6. Judge with a small panel. Three judges, the published criteria, scores written down. A manager does not judge their own reps.
  7. Show the evidence on stage. Play ninety seconds of the winning call or read the buyer's words from the winning deal. The room learns what the behavior sounds like, which is more than a name and a trophy can teach.

Making awards last past the kickoff

Run the behavior awards quarterly, with the annual winner chosen from the quarterly ones. A quarterly discovery call award keeps the behavior in front of reps through the year and gives managers a reason to listen to calls.

Share the winning clip in the team channel the week it is chosen, with two lines from the judges on what made it the winner. Ask the winner to run ten minutes of the next team meeting on how they set up the call. Over a year, that builds a library of real calls from your own market, which new hires can learn from in their first month.

Worked example: an awards block built on one behavior (illustrative)

This example is illustrative. Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm, runs a two-day kickoff for 48 reps and eight managers. The behavior for the year is that discovery calls end with the economic buyer named and a dated next step.

The list has eight awards. Five are results awards from the numbers: top performer, President's Club, team of the year, rookie of the year and biggest new logo. Three are behavior awards: discovery call of the year, coach of the year and lost deal of the year.

Nominations open six weeks out. For the discovery call award, managers submit eleven recordings. Three judges score each against the published criteria: did the call end with the economic buyer named, was the next step dated, and did the rep get there from what the buyer said.

On the night, the winner's ninety-second clip plays before the trophy is handed over. In it, the rep asks a warehouse operations lead who else signs off on a project of that size, and books a date with the finance director before the call ends. The coach of the year goes to a manager whose reps described weekly calls on their live deals. The lost deal award goes to a rep whose review showed she never met the CFO who chose a competitor.

The next morning's deal lab opens with that clip.

Where kickoff awards go wrong

Every award is a results award. The room learns who won and nothing about how. Add behavior awards with evidence.

The criteria are written after the winners are picked. People notice. Publish criteria before nominations, and stick to them.

Too many awards. Twenty categories in a long dinner lose the room by the tenth. Eight to twelve is plenty.

The award contradicts the behavior. A "fastest close" award in a year when the behavior is reaching the economic buyer rewards the shortcut the kickoff is trying to stop. Check each award against the behavior.

Nobody hears what the winner did. A name and a trophy teach nothing. Show the call, the deal or the review.

Coaching the behavior after the ceremony

The ceremony shows what good sounds like. Getting more reps there takes coaching on their own deals in the weeks after, and few managers have time for every rep. Our AI sales experts help: a rep brings a live deal to Caty on a call, by voice or video, and works through it in the team's method before the next buyer conversation. More kickoff ideas with evidence behind them are in which sales kickoff ideas change behavior, and the full event plan is in how to run a sales kickoff. To build the year around one behavior, talk to us.

FAQ

What are good sales kickoff award categories?

Good categories mix results awards, such as top performer and President's Club, with behavior awards judged on evidence, such as discovery call of the year and coach of the year.

How many awards should a sales kickoff have?

Eight to twelve awards is enough for most kickoffs, which keeps the ceremony inside thirty to sixty minutes. Fewer awards with the evidence shown on stage do more than a long list of names.

How do you choose sales award winners fairly?

Publish the criteria before nominations open, collect evidence with each nomination, and have a small panel score against the criteria. A manager should not judge their own reps.

What are creative sales award ideas?

Creative awards that teach something include lost deal of the year for the clearest loss review, best multithreaded deal, and coach of the year nominated by reps.

Should sales kickoff awards include managers?

Managers should have at least one award, usually coach of the year, nominated by their reps with examples of coaching on live deals. Managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment across 1,246 pharma reps (Dahling et al. 2016).

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us