The core sales manager competencies are coaching, deal inspection, forecasting, pipeline management, hiring and running the team's week. Coaching comes first: in one study of 1,246 sales reps, managers' coaching skill predicted goal attainment.
Most new sales managers were promoted because they were good reps. Selling and managing share a vocabulary and little else, and the skills that made someone a top rep can get in the way: they jump in and run the deal, or they coach by telling the rep what they would have done. The competencies below are the ones a new manager has to learn, in roughly the order they need them.
What a sales manager competency is
A sales manager competency is a skill a first-line sales manager needs to get results through a team, defined well enough that someone can watch the manager and say what level they are at.
The definition matters because most lists of manager skills are adjectives: communication, leadership, resilience. They describe a good person and cannot be coached. A competency you can coach names the behavior: "in a deal review, asks for what the buyer said before giving advice". The sales competency model entry covers how to write levels that work.
The person who develops a new manager is usually their own leader, the second-line manager or sales director, with enablement supporting. Building the six competencies to a working level takes most new managers two to three quarters. Coaching takes longest.
The six competencies
Each competency below has what it looks like when it is working. These are written for first-line managers who run a team of six to ten reps.
- CoachingChanges what a rep does on the next call
- Deal inspectionAsks for the buyer evidence
- ForecastingCalls the number from evidence
- Pipeline managementEnough of the right deals, early
- Hiring and rampPicks and ramps reps
- Running the teamStandards, meetings, the week
- CoachingChanges what a rep does on the next call
- Deal inspectionAsks for the buyer evidence
- ForecastingCalls the number from evidence
- Pipeline managementEnough of the right deals, early
- Hiring and rampPicks and ramps reps
- Running the teamStandards, meetings, the week
1. Coaching. The manager changes what a rep does on their next call. They raise one gap at a time, about the rep's capability, with the evidence from a call, and they plan the next conversation with the rep. This is the competency that predicts results. Across 1,246 pharmaceutical sales reps, managers' coaching skill predicted whether reps reached their goals, and frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results (Dahling et al. 2016, via our Game Winning Kickoffs field study).
2. Deal inspection. In a deal review, the manager asks what the buyer has said and done before accepting a stage or a close date. "The champion is bought in" is a feeling; "she forwarded our business case to the CFO" is evidence.
3. Forecasting. The manager calls the team's number from buyer evidence on each deal, and their forecast lands close to the result quarter after quarter.
4. Pipeline management. The manager makes sure each rep has enough of the right deals early enough in the quarter, and spots a rep who is short before it shows in the number.
5. Hiring and ramp. The manager picks reps who can do the job, and gets them to full productivity with a plan, early deal coaching and a clear view of what good looks like.
6. Running the team. The manager sets the standards and runs the meetings that make up the team's week: one-on-ones, the pipeline review and the forecast call. They protect the reps' selling time.
How to coach a new manager into them
The steps below run over a new manager's first two quarters. They put coaching first, because it is the hardest competency and the one that decides results.
1. Assess the starting point
In the first two weeks, sit in on two of the new manager's one-on-ones and one deal review. Mark each competency on a simple three-level scale: not yet, working, strong. Do not share a full scorecard; pick the one or two competencies that need the most work and tell the manager those. Our guide on how to assess sales competencies covers writing levels you can mark.
2. Give them one meeting format
Give the new manager a fixed format for the one-on-one and the deal review, and ask them to use it unchanged for a month. A fixed format stops the new manager from improvising, and makes their meetings easy to observe and compare.
3. Observe and debrief, the same day
Sit in on one coaching conversation a week. Debrief within the day, in fifteen minutes: what the rep will do differently on their next call, whether the manager raised one gap or five, and whether they asked for evidence before giving advice. Pick one thing for next week.
4. Add deal inspection and the forecast
From week four or so, start reviewing the new manager's forecast call with them. Ask how they know each deal will close, and listen for buyer evidence. Compare their call against the result at the end of the month.
5. Rehearse the hard conversations
Before a new manager has a difficult conversation, such as a rep missing for a second quarter or a rep who disputes a forecast call, have them say the opening out loud first. New managers find the opening the hardest part: how to raise a gap so it is about the rep's capability and the number comes second.
6. Check transfer on the reps' deals
At the end of the second quarter, look at the reps' calls and deals. Did the skills the manager coached show up on the reps' calls? That is the test of the manager's coaching, more than how the coaching conversations looked.
A worked example
This example is illustrative. Sam is promoted to lead a team of seven account executives at Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. He was the top rep on the team the year before.
Assessment. His director sits in on two one-on-ones in Sam's second week. In both, the rep describes a stuck deal and Sam tells them what to do within two minutes, before asking what the buyer said. His deal inspection is "not yet", his coaching is "not yet", and his forecasting looks "working".
Format and debrief. His director gives him one rule for a month: in every deal review, ask "what did the buyer say?" twice before giving any advice. After each observed one-on-one, they spend fifteen minutes on whether he kept to it. In week one he does not. By week three he does in most reviews.
Hard conversation. In week seven, one rep misses for the second quarter. Sam rehearses the opening with his director. His first version opens on the number. His second opens on what the rep's calls show about discovery, and the number comes after.
Transfer. By the end of the second quarter, five of seven reps are booking a second meeting with someone more senior than their first contact, the skill Sam has coached most. Two are not, and those become his focus for the next quarter.
Where it goes wrong
Promoting the top rep and leaving them alone. Without observation and debriefs, new managers default to running their reps' deals themselves. It feels productive and it stops the reps learning.
A long list of manager skills. A development plan with twelve competencies produces no change. Two at a time, coaching first, is enough.
Measuring the manager on activity. Counting one-on-ones held says nothing about whether they changed anything. Measure what changed on the reps' calls.
More coaching from a manager who is not yet good at it. In the Dahling study, frequent coaching from less skilled managers was linked to worse results. Build the skill before adding volume.
Which competencies to build first
Build them in the order the new manager meets them. Running the team and deal inspection come up in the first week, because the one-on-ones and the pipeline review are already in the calendar. Coaching starts in the same week and takes longest, so it gets the most observation. Forecasting matters from the first month end. Pipeline management becomes visible a quarter in, when the first gaps show up. Hiring usually comes last, because most new managers inherit a full team.
The order is a guide. A manager who inherits two open roles starts on hiring in week one, and a manager whose team is short of pipeline starts there.
Support for the new manager
A new manager's director cannot sit in on every one-on-one. Most of the new manager's coaching happens alone, and the prep for it happens in the minutes before.
On Replicate Labs, managers have Bryce, our manager coach, for the fifteen minutes before a one-on-one: ask what to raise with this rep, get the evidence, and get an opening line. Bryce's Monday read shows which deals carry buyer evidence and which do not. The new manager then has the conversation. The longer development plan is in how to coach new sales managers, and the sales manager coaching guide covers the coaching itself. To support your new managers this way, talk to us.
FAQ
What are the most important sales manager competencies?
The most important sales manager competencies are coaching, deal inspection, forecasting, pipeline management, hiring and ramp, and running the team. Coaching comes first, because in one large study managers' coaching skill predicted whether reps reached their goals.
How do you develop a new sales manager?
Develop a new sales manager by assessing their starting point and giving them one meeting format. Then observe a coaching conversation each week, debrief the same day, and check the skills show up on reps' calls.
How long does it take a new sales manager to become competent?
Most new sales managers take two to three quarters to reach a working level across the six competencies. Coaching takes longest, because it needs regular observation and feedback.
What is the difference between sales manager skills and sales manager competencies?
Skills are often described as traits, like communication or leadership. A competency names a behavior with levels someone can observe, such as asking for buyer evidence before giving advice.
How do you assess a sales manager's coaching?
Assess a sales manager's coaching by observing their one-on-ones and deal reviews, then checking whether the skill they coached shows up on the reps' later calls. Activity counts say little about quality.