All field notes

Template ·

Sales skills assessment template

A sales skills assessment template to copy: five skills, five levels each with a marker reason, the call evidence, and one skill to coach next quarter.

A sales skills assessment template lists the skills a role needs, defines levels for each, and records the call evidence behind each mark. Copy the one below, mark three real calls per rep, and pick one skill to coach.

The template is built to be marked by a manager on real calls, so every level describes something you can hear. It works for account executives and account managers; for SDRs, swap the skills for the ones listed in the FAQ.

The template

Fill in one copy per rep per quarter. The five skills below suit a new-business account executive; change them to fit the role, and keep the number at four to six.

Skill Level (1 to 5) Call and moment Marker reason
Uncovering the problem
Quantifying the problem
Finding the decision process
Handling an objection
Agreeing a next step
Skill to coach next quarter
How it will be practiced
Date of the next assessment

Use the same five levels for every skill, and write what each one means for that skill before anyone marks a call:

Level Name What it means
1 Missing The skill does not show on the call
2 Attempted The rep tries it once and the buyer moves past it
3 Working The rep does it and gets a usable answer from the buyer
4 Strong The rep does it well, and the buyer adds detail without being asked
5 Model The rep does it in a way that changes how the buyer sees the problem

How to use the template

The template is only as good as its levels and the calls it is marked on. Follow the steps in order the first time.

One skill, five levels
  1. 11. MissingThe skill does not show on the call
  2. 22. AttemptedTried once, the buyer moved past it
  3. 33. WorkingDone, with a usable answer from the buyer
  4. 44. StrongDone well, and the buyer adds detail
  5. 55. ModelChanges how the buyer sees the problem
  1. Choose the skills for the role. Pick four to six. Use the skills that most affect results in that role, in the words your team already sells with. If you run a named method, use its terms.
  2. Write the levels for each skill. For each skill, write a sentence for each of the five levels that describes what a person would hear on a call. "Asks good questions" cannot be marked; "asks how the problem shows up in the buyer's numbers, and gets a figure" can.
  3. Add a marker reason to each level. Find one real call for each level and write a short reason why it sits there and not one above. In our call-scoring research, assessors' own reasons for their marks gave the biggest single gain in how closely AI scores matched human ones (field guide). They help human markers the same way.
  4. Pick three calls per rep. Choose calls where each skill should show. Discovery skills are marked on first meetings, objection handling on later calls. One call can be a bad day, so take the level the rep reaches on most calls.
  5. Mark each skill on its own. For each skill, note the call, the minute and what was said. A mark without a moment is an opinion.
  6. Have a second marker check a few. Ask another manager or someone from enablement to mark one call per rep. Where you disagree, rewrite the level description.
  7. Pick one skill and book the next assessment. Choose the skill to coach next quarter, write how it will be practiced, and put the date of the next assessment on the template before you close it.

The deeper guide to each step is how to assess sales competencies.

Adapting it for other roles

The level structure stays the same across roles. The skills change, because each role's calls test different things.

For account managers, replace the new-business skills with the ones their customer conversations need: confirming value in the customer's own measures, naming a miss before the customer does, asking about the customer's next 90 days, asking for an introduction to another team, and handling a renewal objection. Mark them on QBRs and renewal calls.

For sales managers, the template works on one-on-ones and deal reviews: asking for buyer evidence before giving advice, raising one gap at a time, planning the next conversation with the rep, and calling the forecast from evidence. A second-line manager or sales director marks it.

For any role, write the level sentences in the team's own words. A level description your managers would never say out loud will not get used.

A filled-in example

This example is illustrative. Jordan is an account executive at Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm that sells freight management to manufacturers. Their manager marks three first meetings from the quarter.

Skill Level Call and moment Marker reason
Uncovering the problem 4 Call 2, minute 6 Buyer described late shipments, then added the cost of the overtime it causes
Quantifying the problem 2 Call 1, minute 14 Asked "what does that cost you?" once; buyer said "a lot" and Jordan moved on
Finding the decision process 2 Call 3, minute 22 Asked who else is involved; accepted "just me for now"
Handling an objection 3 Call 2, minute 18 Asked what was behind the price concern before answering it
Agreeing a next step 3 Call 1, minute 28 Booked a date and time, but with the same contact only
Skill to coach next quarter Quantifying the problem Shows on every call, lowest mark, affects the business case
How it will be practiced One deal review a week on a live deal, plus a practice conversation before key first meetings
Date of the next assessment First week of next quarter

Jordan is good at getting the buyer talking about the problem and weak at putting a number on it. Quantifying the problem is the skill to coach first, because without a figure the business case later in the deal has nothing to stand on. The decision process gap matters too, and comes next quarter.

The manager does not share all five scores in a list. They open the debrief with one moment from call 1 and ask Jordan what they could have asked after "a lot".

Three ways teams misuse it

Self-assessment. Handing the template to the rep to fill in turns it into a confidence survey. Reps rate themselves on how comfortable they feel, which is often unrelated to what happens on calls. Ask reps where they want help, but mark the template from calls.

Scoring everything, coaching nothing. A team that fills in the template for every rep and then files it has a spreadsheet and no change. The bottom three rows are the point of the template. If they are empty, the assessment did not happen.

Changing the levels between assessments. If the level descriptions change between the first and second assessment, the two cannot be compared. Fix the levels after the first round of disagreement checks, then keep them for at least two quarters.

Using the template every quarter

The template takes a manager about an hour per rep per quarter: three calls, five skills, a short debrief. For a team of eight that is a full day, which is why many teams mark it once and stop.

AI scoring can take the first pass if the scorer is tested on how well it ranks calls. Our research found that a scorer can look accurate on average while ignoring the transcript, so test it on ranking. For certification, the related sales certification rubric template uses the same level structure. Once the skill to coach is chosen, our sales coaching framework covers the brief, observe and debrief loop, and reps can work on the deals where the skill shows up with Caty, one of our AI sales experts, by voice or video on a call. For enablers shows how teams set it up, or talk to us.

FAQ

How many calls do you need to assess a rep?

Mark at least three calls per rep for each assessment, chosen so each skill has a chance to show. One call can be a bad day, so take the level the rep reaches on most of them.

What is a sales skills assessment?

A sales skills assessment is a structured judgment of a rep's level on defined sales skills. The most useful versions are marked by a manager on real calls against written levels.

What skills should a sales skills assessment include?

A sales skills assessment for an account executive usually covers uncovering the problem, quantifying it, finding the decision process, handling objections and agreeing next steps. Keep it to four to six skills per role.

How do you assess an SDR's sales skills?

Assess an SDR on the skills their calls need: opening a cold call, earning the next thirty seconds, uncovering a problem worth a meeting, handling the first objection and booking the meeting. Use the same five levels.

How often should you run a sales skills assessment?

Run a sales skills assessment once a quarter with the same levels, so each round shows whether the coached skill moved. Book the next assessment date when you finish the current one.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us