All field notes

How-to ·

The Sandler submarine: the seven steps and how to coach each one

The Sandler submarine has seven steps, from bonding and rapport to post-sell. What each compartment means, how managers coach it, and a worked example.

The Sandler submarine is the Sandler Selling System's seven steps: bonding and rapport, up-front contracts, pain, budget, decision, fulfillment and post-sell. Each compartment is sealed before the next, so the buyer cannot drift back.

This guide covers what each compartment means in Sandler's own description, then how a manager coaches each one on a live deal, with a worked example and the places teams most often go wrong.

What the job is, and who does it

The job is running a sale through all seven compartments in order, and checking, deal by deal, that each one is sealed. The rep does the selling; the front-line manager does the checking, usually in a weekly 1:1 or a deal review of 20 to 30 minutes per deal.

David Sandler, the founder of Sandler Training, chose the submarine as the image for a reason Sandler explains on its own blog. Submarines run silently and deep, while other ships advertise their intentions. When flooding threatens, the crew closes each compartment behind them. The selling system works the same way: "sealing each compartment behind you so the prospect cannot go backwards." A prospect can also be disqualified at any compartment, which is a valid result in Sandler.

Sandler's closing line on the idea sets the standard for a manager. Sandler never guaranteed every voyage would end in a sale, "but it should never, ever, end in a 'think-it-over.'"

The seven compartments

Sandler groups the seven compartments into three phases: establishing the relationship, qualifying, and closing. The qualifying phase, pain, budget and decision, sits in the middle and decides whether there is a deal at all.

The seven compartments in three phases
  1. RelationshipSet up the conversation
    • Bonding and rapport
    • Up-front contracts
  2. QualifyingDecide whether there is a deal
    • Pain
    • Budget
    • Decision
  3. ClosingPresent, then secure it
    • Fulfillment
    • Post-sell
Compartment What Sandler says it does What a sealed compartment looks like
Bonding and rapport Builds the connection the rest of the relationship depends on The buyer talks openly and asks questions back
Up-front contracts Agrees how both sides will interact, and continues through the sale Purpose, agendas, time and outcomes agreed, including that no is fine
Pain Identifies what the prospect wants and needs The buyer has stated the problem, its cost and their personal stake
Budget Determines what the prospect is willing and able to spend A figure or range from the buyer, agreed before any solution
Decision Establishes how the prospect will make the decision Who decides, how, and by when, in the buyer's words
Fulfillment Presents solutions that fit the decision process, then asks for the decision A presentation aimed only at the stated pain, ending in a yes or no
Post-sell Resolves issues that could cause a back-out, and opens referrals The buyer has said what could still derail it, and it is handled

Order matters here. A rep presents only in fulfillment, after the buyer has described the pain, agreed the money and explained the decision. Presenting earlier gives the buyer the advice for free. The upfront contract entry covers the second compartment in detail.

How to coach the submarine on a live deal

Coach one compartment at a time, in order, and stop at the first one that is open. A manager who reviews fulfillment before checking pain is coaching a presentation to a problem nobody has confirmed.

  1. Bonding and rapport: ask how the buyer talks. "Is the buyer asking you questions, or only answering yours?" A buyer who only answers is still guarded.
  2. Up-front contract: ask for the agreed outcome. "What did you and the buyer agree this meeting was for, and what would count as a no?" If the rep cannot say, there was no contract.
  3. Pain: ask how far down the buyer went. "What did the buyer say this costs, and how do they feel about it?" A surface problem is an open compartment; the cost and the personal stake seal it. The pain funnel gives the questions.
  4. Budget: ask whose number it is. "Did the buyer give the figure, or did you suggest it?" A budget the rep proposed and the buyer nodded at is unsealed.
  5. Decision: ask for the buyer's own account. "Who told you how they decide, and in what words?" A process guessed from the org chart leaves water in the boat.
  6. Fulfillment: ask what the presentation was aimed at. "Which pain did each part of the demo answer?" Anything that answered none of them was free consulting.
  7. Post-sell: ask what could still undo it. "What did the buyer say might stop this after they signed?" A rep who never asked will meet the answer later, as buyer's remorse.

Each question has a clear test: the buyer's words, or the rep's guess. Sandler teaches reps to treat no as an acceptable outcome, and managers should apply the same rule to their own reviews. A deal disqualified at budget is a sealed compartment, and a better use of the quarter than a deal carried to fulfillment on hope.

A worked example

This example is illustrative. A rep is selling a training platform to Arrowmere, an invented 600-person logistics firm. The buyer is the head of operations. The manager walks the deal through the submarine in a 25-minute review.

Bonding and rapport. The buyer asked about other logistics customers and booked the second meeting themselves. Sealed.

Up-front contract. The rep opened the last meeting by agreeing they would decide whether to bring in finance, and that no was a fine answer. Sealed.

Pain. The rep has "new depot staff take too long to get productive", plus the cost: about two months of reduced output per hire, across 80 hires a year. The buyer added that they present the shortfall to the board. Sealed, with the cost and personal stake in the buyer's words.

Budget. The rep says, "They seemed fine with the ballpark." The manager asks whose ballpark it was. The rep had offered a range and the buyer said "that's in the area". Open.

Decision. The rep believes the head of operations decides. Nobody has asked the buyer how purchases of this size are approved. Open.

The manager stops there. Fulfillment and post-sell are not discussed, because the deal is not ready for them. The plan for the next meeting is two questions: "What have you set aside for this?" and "Walk me through how a purchase like this gets approved." The rep sets an up-front contract for that meeting: if the budget and approval process do not fit, they will both agree to stop.

Two weeks later the rep reports back. The buyer named a budget held for operations training, lower than the rep's original range but enough for the first two depots. Approval runs through the finance lead and the chief operating officer, who signs anything over a set amount. Both compartments are now sealed in the buyer's words. Only then does the manager turn to fulfillment: the rep will present to the head of operations and the finance lead together, aimed only at the onboarding cost they described, and ask for a decision at the end of that meeting. For post-sell, the rep plans one question after any yes: "What could stop this going ahead once you have signed?"

Where it goes wrong

Most submarine failures come from moving to the next compartment with the last one still open. Five patterns come up often.

  • Presenting before the qualifying phase. The buyer asks for a demo, the rep agrees, and pain, budget and decision are skipped. The likely result is the think-it-over Sandler warns about.
  • Treating the up-front contract as a one-off. Sandler describes it as continuing through the sale. A meeting that changes topic, such as moving to price, needs a fresh agreement.
  • Accepting a rep's summary as a sealed compartment. "Budget is fine" is the rep's view. The test is what the buyer said.
  • Treating a disqualified deal as a failure. A rep who learns at budget that the money is not there, and stops, has done the job. Managers who punish that result teach reps to keep weak deals alive until fulfillment, where they cost the most time.
  • Skipping post-sell. The deal closes and the rep moves on, without asking what could cause the buyer to back out or who else might benefit. That is where cancellations and lost referrals start.

Coaching every compartment on every deal

Few managers have time to walk every deal through seven compartments each week, which is why reviews drift to the deals that are about to close. How to run a Sandler deal review sets out a format for the ones that get a manager's time.

Replicate Labs builds AI sales experts that coach the method a team already runs. For Sandler, that expert is Caty. A Sandler team loads its own playbook, and the rep talks each deal through with Caty by voice or video on a call, before and after each buyer meeting, so every open compartment gets named (master your sales methodology). Replicate Labs has no partnership with Sandler Training. The Sandler Selling System entry covers the method as a whole. To set it up on your playbook, talk to us.

FAQ

What are the seven steps of the Sandler submarine?

The seven steps are bonding and rapport, up-front contracts, pain, budget, decision, fulfillment and post-sell. Sandler groups them into relationship, qualifying and closing phases.

Why is it called the Sandler submarine?

David Sandler chose a submarine because it runs silently and seals each compartment behind the crew. The selling system seals each step so the prospect cannot go backwards.

What is the most important step in the Sandler submarine?

The pain compartment is often treated as the most important, because budget and decision depend on it. Sandler's own description gives each compartment a job, and a deal can be disqualified at any of them.

What comes after the up-front contract in Sandler?

Pain comes after the up-front contract in the Sandler submarine. The rep uses questions such as the pain funnel to learn the problem, its cost and the buyer's personal stake.

Has the Sandler submarine changed?

Sandler introduced a new look for the submarine and says its principles are unchanged. Its current description still lists the seven compartments in the same order.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us