All field notes

Template ·

Win-loss interview questions: a 30-minute template for won, lost and no-decision deals

Win-loss interview questions in a copyable 30-minute template: the problem, the options, the approvals and the seller, with wording for wins and losses.

Good win-loss interview questions ask how the decision was made before asking why: who was involved, what problem the buyer was solving, what else they weighed, what set the timing and what nearly changed the outcome.

The template below runs as a 30-minute call with one buyer, a few weeks after the decision. It works for won deals, lost deals and deals that ended in no decision, with small changes to the wording that are listed after the questions. Copy it into a doc, keep the order, and change as little as you can from one interview to the next so the answers compare.

The win-loss interview question template

Six sections, 23 questions, 30 minutes. The middle two sections carry most of the learning, so protect their time if the call runs short.

The 30-minute win-loss interview
  1. 01Opening2 minutes: role and who else to ask
  2. 02The problem and the timing5 minutes: what it cost to leave alone
  3. 03The options7 minutes: everything they weighed
  4. 04The decision and the approvals7 minutes: who decided and what nearly changed it
  5. 05The seller5 minutes: what helped and what slowed them
  6. 06Close4 minutes: the reason in one sentence

1. Opening (2 minutes)

  1. What is your role, and what part did you play in this decision?
  2. Who else would I need to speak to for the full picture?

2. The problem and the timing (5 minutes)

  1. What problem were you trying to solve when you started looking?
  2. What was it costing you to leave it alone?
  3. What happened that made this the time to act?
  4. If you had done nothing, what would have happened over the next year?

3. The options (7 minutes)

  1. What else did you consider, including keeping things as they were or building it yourselves?
  2. How did each option come onto your list?
  3. What did an option have to show before it made the shortlist?
  4. Which criteria mattered most by the end, and did they change along the way?
  5. Where did the option you chose pull ahead?

4. The decision and the approvals (7 minutes)

  1. Who was involved in the decision, and who had the final say?
  2. Who was most in favor, who was most doubtful, and what were their reasons?
  3. What did the approval process involve after your team agreed: legal, security, procurement, finance?
  4. What nearly changed the outcome?
  5. When did you know which way it would go?

5. The seller (5 minutes)

  1. What did our rep do that helped you decide?
  2. Where did our process slow you down or make your job harder?
  3. Was there anyone on your side who never heard why this mattered?
  4. What would you tell the rep to do differently next time?

6. Close (4 minutes)

  1. In one sentence, why did you choose the option you chose?
  2. Is there anything I should have asked and did not?
  3. May we check back in six months to see how it went?

Wording for wins, losses and no decision

The questions stay the same across outcomes. A few need a different frame so the buyer can answer without feeling defensive.

Question Won deal Lost deal No decision
5 What made this the time to act? What made this the time to act? What would have to happen for this to become urgent?
11 Where did we pull ahead? Where did the option you chose pull ahead? Which option came closest, and what held it back?
15 What nearly made you choose someone else? What nearly made you choose us? What nearly got this approved?
21 Why us, in one sentence? Why them, in one sentence? Why wait, in one sentence?

How to use the template

  1. Pick the deals by rule. Choose five to ten closed deals a month from the last 30 to 60 days, mixing wins, losses and no-decisions above a size that matters. The same rule each month keeps the counts comparable. The win-loss analysis guide covers the selection in full.
  2. Get the rep's view in writing first. Before the call, the rep writes one line on why the deal went the way it did. That line cannot change after the buyer speaks, because the gap between the two accounts is often the finding.
  3. Choose an interviewer outside the deal. Buyers speak more freely to someone they did not turn down or negotiate with. A manager from another team, RevOps or an outside firm can run it; the piece on who should own win-loss analysis weighs the options.
  4. Ask in order, and follow the answer. Use the numbered questions as the spine and ask "what happened next?" when an answer opens a door. Sections 3 and 4 are where buyers describe the moment the deal turned.
  5. Write down the buyer's words. Quote the phrases that carry the reason, such as "our CFO never saw the numbers". Summaries in the interviewer's language lose the detail a manager needs later.
  6. Code the answers to evidence within a day. For each deal, mark what the buyer confirms was present or missing: the signer heard the case, a buyer put a cost on the problem, the approval steps were known, the alternatives were addressed, the date came from the buyer's side. The deal risk guide lists the evidence each stage should carry.
  7. Take the top code to open deals the same week. Search the pipeline for deals missing the same evidence today and give each one a planned conversation with a date.

A filled-in example

This example is illustrative. A software vendor lost a route planning deal at Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. The rep's written view, before the interview, said "lost on price; the other vendor came in lower."

A sales manager from a different region ran the 30-minute call with Arrowmere's operations director. The notes, kept in the buyer's words where it mattered:

  • Problem and timing (questions 3 to 6): late starts at two depots were pushing drivers into overtime. A new delivery contract with tighter windows was due in the spring, which set the timing.
  • Options (questions 7 to 11): two vendors and staying with spreadsheets. The winner "showed us our own routes in the second meeting."
  • Decision (questions 12 to 16): the finance director had the final say and joined one call, the last one. "She asked what the overtime was costing and nobody on your side had a number." Question 15 drew the key answer: "If she had seen the cost earlier, price would not have come up."
  • Seller (questions 17 to 20): the rep was responsive and the demo was strong. "We had to explain your proposal to her ourselves."
  • Close (question 21): "The other team made the case to the person who signs."

Coded to evidence, the deal had no point where the signer heard the case, and no buyer had put a cost on the problem. The price reason in the CRM was the visible symptom. The manager searched open deals past discovery where the signer had not joined a call and found nine across five reps, each of which got a planned conversation with the champion about bringing the signer in.

Three common misuses

Asking why before how. Opening with "why did you choose them?" gets a short, polite answer, usually price or features. Buyers find "who was in the final meeting?" easier to answer, and the reason tends to come out in the story.

Letting the rep run the interview. The rep who lost the deal hears a softer version of events, and the buyer may avoid criticizing someone they liked. Keep the rep out of the call and share the notes afterwards.

Collecting answers that never reach a deal. A quarterly deck of themes changes little on its own. If no open deal gets a planned conversation in the week a finding lands, the interviews have produced research and nothing more.

Turning the answers into coaching

The coaching happens on open deals. Each rep can bring a flagged deal to Caty by voice or video on a call, talk it through in the team's own method, and leave with the conversation that fills the gap. Managers see which deals carry buyer evidence through Bryce, and the for leaders page shows how the two fit together. If your last round of win-loss interviews ended as a slide, talk to us.

FAQ

What questions should you ask in a win-loss interview?

Ask about the problem and its cost, the timing, every option considered, who decided, the approval steps, what nearly changed the outcome and what the seller could have done better, in that order.

How long should a win-loss interview be?

A win-loss interview usually runs 20 to 30 minutes. Busy buyers say yes to half an hour more readily than to an hour, and 30 minutes still leaves room for the options and the decision.

Who should conduct a win-loss interview?

Someone outside the deal team should conduct it: a manager from another team, RevOps or an outside firm. Buyers are more candid with a person they did not negotiate with or turn down.

When should you do a win-loss interview after a decision?

Interview the buyer within a few weeks of the decision, while the details are fresh. After two or three months, buyers remember the outcome and lose the sequence of events that explains it.

Should you interview buyers on won deals too?

Interview buyers on won deals as well as lost ones. Wins show which evidence was present when deals closed, so the team has something to compare each loss with.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us