Before and after scenarios are two descriptions a seller builds with a buyer: the Before Scenario is the situation today, with its problems and costs, and the After Scenario is the situation once the problem is solved.
The terms are best known from Force Management's Command of the Message method, where the seller's job is to move the customer "from the Before to the After Scenario." Marketers use a looser version of the same idea, the before-and-after story, where a customer's results are shown on either side of a change.
How before and after scenarios work in a sales team
The Before Scenario comes first and does most of the work. It is the buyer's own account of what is going wrong, who it affects and what it costs. A rep builds it in discovery by asking about the current process and its consequences, then playing it back until the buyer agrees it is accurate.
- 01Before ScenarioThe problem today and what it costs
- 02Required capabilitiesWhat must change to get there
- 03After ScenarioThe situation once it is solved
- 04Positive business outcomeThe result the business reports
The After Scenario is the buyer's picture of the same work once the problem is gone. Force Management notes a common gap here: a buyer often has "a desired future state, but not necessarily a defined way to get there." The seller's job is to connect the two with the required capabilities a solution needs, and to link the After Scenario to the positive business outcomes the business will report.
Teams use the pair in four places:
- Discovery. The rep's questions aim to fill in a Before Scenario the buyer would sign.
- The value framework. Each row of a value framework starts from a typical Before Scenario for a buyer role.
- The deal review. A manager checks whether the Before Scenario is in the buyer's words and whether the After Scenario carries a measure.
- The proposal. The business case restates both, so the economic buyer sees the change they are paying for.
Before Scenario and current state
Other methods name the same idea differently. Gap Selling, from A Sales Growth Company, uses current state and future state, with the gap between them as the size of the problem. The words differ and the discipline is similar: describe today accurately before talking about tomorrow. A team should use the words its own method uses, so deal reviews and CRM fields stay consistent.
Example
This example is illustrative. A rep sells route-planning software to Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. After discovery, the rep writes both scenarios and reads them back to the transport manager.
- Before Scenario. Planners build next-day routes by hand each afternoon. When an order changes after 4 p.m., the plan is redone. Drivers often finish late, and the firm pays overtime most weeks. Two customers complained about missed delivery windows last quarter.
- After Scenario. Routes are rebuilt automatically when an order changes. Planners spend the afternoon on exceptions. Drivers finish within their shifts, and delivery windows are met for the customers who complained.
The transport manager corrects one detail: changes after 3 p.m. are the problem, so the rep updates it. That correction is a good sign. A buyer who edits the Before Scenario has read it closely and accepted the rest.
In the deal review, the manager asks what the After Scenario is worth and to whom. The rep has the overtime cost from finance and the names of the two customers. Both go into the business case.
Common mistakes
- Writing the Before Scenario from the product. "They lack automated routing" describes a missing feature. "Planners redo the routes every afternoon" describes the buyer's day.
- Skipping the cost. A Before Scenario with no cost attached gives the buyer no reason to change this quarter.
- An After Scenario with no measure. "Things run smoothly" cannot be checked. Tie it to a number the buyer tracks.
Related terms
- What is Command of the Message?: the method the terms come from
- What are current state and future state?: the Gap Selling version of the same idea
- How to build a sales value framework: where both scenarios sit in the grid
- Sales methodology guide: how methods compare
Teams that run Command of the Message or a house method can rehearse discovery on a live deal with Caty, our AI sales expert, by voice or video on a call. See coaching your own methodology on live deals.
FAQ
What is a Before Scenario in Command of the Message?
A Before Scenario is the buyer's situation today, including the problems they face and what those problems cost. In Command of the Message, the seller's job is to move the customer from the Before to the After Scenario.
What is an After Scenario?
An After Scenario describes how the buyer's work looks once the problem is solved. It should connect to a positive business outcome and a measure the buyer already tracks.
How do you build a Before Scenario in discovery?
Ask about the current process, what goes wrong, who it affects and what it costs, then play it back to the buyer. The Before Scenario is ready when the buyer agrees it is accurate.
Are before and after scenarios the same as current and future state?
They describe similar ideas in two different methods. Before and after scenarios come from Command of the Message, while current state and future state come from Gap Selling.