The three whys are the questions a buyer must answer before they buy: why change from what they do today, why act now, and why choose this seller over every alternative, including doing nothing.
Sellers use the three whys to test whether a deal has a real case for change. If the buyer cannot answer the first two in their own words, the third rarely matters.
How the three whys work in a sales team
The three whys run in order, and the order matters. Many reps start with why us, because that is the part they know best, and pitch differentiators to a buyer who has not yet decided to change anything.
- 01Why change?The status quo is costing something
- 02Why now?Waiting has a cost or a deadline
- 03Why us?This option beats the alternatives
Why change asks whether the status quo is costing the buyer enough to act. The answer is a problem with a cost the buyer accepts. Why now asks why the buyer should act this quarter. The answer is a deadline, an event or a cost that grows with each month of delay. Why us asks why this seller's approach beats the alternatives, and the alternatives include hiring, building it in-house and doing nothing.
Several sales trainers build on the same idea. Corporate Visions builds a training course around Why Change, warning that without a compelling reason to change, buyers conclude they can live with their current situation and the deal ends in "no decision"; its wider sequence also includes why now and why you. Bob Apollo of Inflexion-Point adds a fourth question, why trust you, for buyers wary of a new supplier. GitLab's public handbook shows the questions inside a Command of the Message deal plan, which asks why do anything at all and why now.
| Question | What the buyer must believe | Evidence a manager looks for |
|---|---|---|
| Why change? | Staying put costs more than changing | The problem and its cost, in the buyer's words |
| Why now? | Waiting makes it worse | A date or event on the buyer's side |
| Why us? | This option beats the others, including doing nothing | The criteria the buyer will compare on, and where the seller wins |
Using the three whys in a deal review
A manager can run the three whys as a quick test on any deal. The rep answers each one, and the manager asks who said it.
- Why change. Ask the rep to state the buyer's problem and what it costs. If the cost is the rep's estimate, the deal has no case for change yet.
- Why now. Ask what happens on the buyer's side if this slips a quarter. "End of our quarter" is the seller's deadline, and it does not count.
- Why us. Ask what the buyer will compare on and what the next best option is. If the rep has only listed rival vendors, doing nothing is the missing competitor.
The weakest answer sets the next call. This fits any method, and most named methods have their own version: the commercial insight in Challenger is a way of answering why change, and a sales value framework prepares the answers to why us in advance.
Example
This example is illustrative. A rep is selling a route planning system to Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm, and the deal has stalled after a strong demo.
In the review, the manager runs the three whys. Why us is strong: the rep can list four features the rival lacks. Why change is thin: the operations director said late starts are "annoying" but never put a cost on them. Why now is missing.
On the next call the rep asks two questions. What did late starts cost in overtime last quarter? And is anything coming up that makes them more expensive? The director says a new contract with tighter delivery windows starts in the spring. That one answer gives the deal a why change and a why now, and the features finally have a reason to matter.
Related terms
- What is a commercial insight?
- How to build a sales value framework
- The sales methodology guide
- Coaching a team's own methodology on live deals
FAQ
What are the three whys in sales?
The three whys are why change, why now and why us: the questions a buyer answers before they commit. Sellers use them to check that a deal has a case for change, urgency and a reason to choose them.
Why does why change come first?
A buyer who sees no reason to change will not care why a seller is different. Corporate Visions warns that without a compelling reason to change, buyers stay with their current situation and deals end in no decision.
What is the fourth why?
Bob Apollo of Inflexion-Point adds why trust you, for buyers who need confidence that a new or unfamiliar supplier will deliver. Other trainers extend the list into later decisions, such as why pay and why stay.
Is "why us" the same as a value proposition?
Why us is the buyer's question, and a value proposition is the seller's answer to it. A good answer names the buyer's own criteria and compares against every option, including doing nothing.
How do you answer why now in a sales call?
Answer why now with a date or event on the buyer's side: a contract start, a renewal, a regulation or a cost that grows each month. A seller's quarter end does not count.