Solution selling suits buyers who know something is wrong and want help diagnosing it. Challenger suits buyers who think they already know the answer, or who see no reason to change. Many teams use both, depending on the deal.
The two share a starting point: neither leads with the product. They part ways on who frames the problem. In solution selling, the rep draws the problem out of the buyer with questions. In Challenger, the rep brings an insight about the buyer's business that the buyer had not seen.
What solution selling is
Solution selling is a sales approach in which the rep diagnoses the buyer's business problem first and then proposes the product as the fix for that problem. It took shape in the 1980s as a reaction to feature-led selling.
The term is both generic and a brand. Many teams say they "run solution selling" when they mean reps are expected to diagnose before they pitch. Richardson Sales Performance teaches a named Solution Selling program, which it describes as an end-to-end sales system built on keeping the seller's attention on solving the buyer's business problems.
The shared core most solution selling programs teach runs in a sequence: find the pain, size it in the buyer's numbers, find who owns it, build a picture of the fixed state with the buyer, then show only the capabilities that close the gap. The rep's main job is to diagnose well. Our page of solution selling examples shows the questions at each step.
What Challenger is
The Challenger Sale is a sales methodology in which reps teach buyers a new insight about their business, tailor it to each stakeholder and take control of the sale. It comes from research by Matt Dixon and Brent Adamson at CEB, now part of Gartner, published as a book in 2011.
The authors studied more than 6,000 reps and sorted them into five seller profiles. They report that nearly 40% of high performers were Challengers, and that Relationship Builders were the least represented, at 7%. Challenger Inc. trains teams in the method today.
The working part of Challenger is the commercial insight: a short argument that breaks a belief the buyer holds about their business and leads to something only the seller's company does well. Reps then tailor that insight to what each stakeholder is measured on, and take control by talking about money and asking for commitments. Our Challenger Sale book summary covers the research and the six-step pitch in more depth.
Solution selling vs Challenger at a glance
The cleanest way to compare them is by what the rep does in the first meeting and where the problem definition comes from.
| Solution selling | Challenger | |
|---|---|---|
| Who frames the problem | The buyer, drawn out by the rep's questions | The rep, through a commercial insight |
| First meeting opens with | Questions about how the business works today | A view of the buyer's business they had not considered |
| The rep's core skill | Diagnosis | Teaching and reframing |
| Built centrally or by each rep | Mostly by each rep, deal by deal | The insight is built centrally; reps tailor it |
| Tension with the buyer | Kept low; the rep is a careful listener | Used on purpose to move the buyer off the status quo |
| Fits best when | The buyer knows something is wrong and is open to help | The buyer has a settled view or sees no reason to change |
| Typical failure | A long discovery on a buyer who already researched the answer | An "insight" the buyer already knew, delivered as a lecture |
The argument between them
In 2012, Adamson, Dixon and Nicholas Toman published "The End of Solution Sales" in Harvard Business Review. Their argument was that buyers had become better at defining their own needs before meeting a supplier, so a rep who waits to be told the problem arrives late and competes on price.
Solution selling's defenders answer that a buyer who arrives with a self-diagnosis is often wrong about the cause, and good diagnostic questions find that out. Both camps agree on more than the titles suggest. Each says the rep must understand the buyer's business better than a product pitch requires. They disagree on whether the rep should ask their way to the problem or bring it.
Where each falls short
Each approach has a known way of going wrong, and managers hear both in deal reviews.
Solution selling goes wrong when the rep treats discovery as a script. A buyer who has spent a month researching the problem does not want twenty questions about how the process works today. The rep has to show they already understand the situation and spend the call on what the research missed.
Challenger goes wrong when the insight is thin or the delivery is arrogant. If the buyer already knew the "insight," the rep has spent their credibility on nothing. And taking control is easy to mistake for pushing, which buyers on long, high-stakes purchases tend to punish.
Which one fits your deals
The choice turns on two things about the buyer: how clear their view of the problem is, and how firmly they hold it.
When the buyer's view is settled, whether the problem is vague or clear, Challenger has the edge. A settled buyer will not discover a new problem through questions alone, so the rep has to bring the insight, either teaching a new view or reframing the cause the buyer has assumed. When the buyer is open, solution selling fits: diagnose together if the problem is vague, or size it and match the capability if the problem is already clear.
Most teams find their deals fall in more than one box. That is why many run a single method as their house language and teach managers to coach the other behavior where it fits. The sales methodology guide covers the wider set of options.
One deal, run both ways
This example is illustrative. A rep is selling a route planning system to Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. The operations director has agreed to a first meeting.
Run as solution selling, the rep opens with questions. How are routes planned each morning? Where does it break? The director says dispatchers plan by hand and trucks often leave late. The rep asks what a late start costs. The director estimates overtime every week. The rep asks who else feels it, finds the finance lead, and only then shows the automatic route plan.
Run as Challenger, the rep opens with an insight prepared in advance. Firms of Arrowmere's size tend to blame late starts on driver availability, the rep says, but the bigger cost usually sits in the first plan of the day, because every later adjustment inherits its errors. The director had been planning to hire another dispatcher. The rep tailors the same point for the finance lead as a cost question, and asks for a meeting with both of them to test it on Arrowmere's own numbers.
Both versions keep the product out of the first ten minutes. In the first version, the director's own estimate of overtime carries the deal. In the second, the rep's insight has to survive a test on Arrowmere's numbers, and if it does not, the rep has lost credibility with two people at once.
What a manager listens for in each
The two approaches leave different traces on a call recording and in the CRM, so a manager coaching them listens for different things.
On a solution selling deal, the manager listens for the buyer doing most of the talking in the first meeting, and for the problem stated in the buyer's words with a cost attached. The useful review questions are short:
- "What did the buyer say the problem costs, and who said it?"
- "Who else feels this problem, and have you spoken to them?"
- "What did you show, and which part of the problem did it close?"
On a Challenger deal, the manager listens for the moment the buyer's view shifted. A good sign is the buyer repeating the insight back in their own terms, or asking a question that shows they are now thinking about the problem differently. The review questions change:
- "What did the buyer believe before the meeting, and what do they believe now?"
- "How did you tailor the insight for each person in the room?"
- "What commitment did you ask for, and what did they say?"
If a rep cannot answer the first question in either list, the approach has not landed, whatever the rep's notes say.
Coaching either approach on live deals
Both approaches are learned on live deals, in the week after training, when a manager listens to a call and asks what the buyer said. Most managers do not have time for that on every deal.
Caty, our AI sales expert for Challenger, solution selling and other methods, coaches reps on their live deals in the team's own method, by voice or video on a call. For teams building a shared language across methods, coaching a team's own methodology explains how it works. To see it on your deals, talk to us.
FAQ
What is the main difference between solution selling and Challenger?
Solution selling draws the problem out of the buyer with questions, while Challenger brings the buyer an insight about a problem they had not seen. Both avoid leading with the product.
Is Challenger better than solution selling?
Neither wins in every deal; Challenger fits buyers with a settled view of the problem, and solution selling fits buyers who are open and want help with the diagnosis. Many teams coach both behaviors.
Who created the Challenger Sale?
Matt Dixon and Brent Adamson created the Challenger Sale from research at CEB, now part of Gartner, and published the book in 2011. Challenger Inc. trains teams in the method today.
Is solution selling still used?
Solution selling is still widely used, both as a general idea that reps diagnose before they pitch and as a named program. Richardson Sales Performance teaches a Solution Selling program today.
Can a rep use both solution selling and Challenger?
A rep can use both, choosing by buyer: diagnose with questions when the buyer is open, bring an insight when the buyer's view is settled. Teams usually still pick one as their house language.
What did "The End of Solution Sales" argue?
The 2012 Harvard Business Review article argued that buyers now define their own needs before meeting suppliers, so reps who wait to be told the problem arrive late. Its authors were Adamson, Dixon and Toman.