The glossary

Glossary

What is a problem identification chart?

A problem identification chart (PIC) is a Gap Selling reference that lists the problems a product solves, the root causes behind each one and the business impacts they create.

A Sales Growth Company (ASG), the firm Jim Keenan founded, developed the PIC from Gap Selling. A team builds it once per product, before any call, and every rep diagnoses each deal against it. It gives marketing, sales, enablement and product one shared description of why customers buy.

The three columns

ASG defines the chart with three parts. Each row starts from one problem and fills in what creates it and what it causes.

One row of a problem identification chart
  1. 01Root causeThe specific, fixable issue
  2. 02ProblemThe high-level business challenge
  3. 03ImpactWhat it costs when it persists
Column ASG's definition Example (illustrative)
Problem The high-level business challenge the buyer faces Missing quarterly revenue targets
Root causes The specific, fixable issues that create the problem Inaccurate CRM data, low outbound activity, no ramp training for new reps
Impacts The tangible business consequences when the problem persists Missed guidance, lost market share, pressure on the stock

The middle column is the one reps skip. A problem with no root cause gives the rep nothing to fix, and a problem with no impact gives the buyer no reason to act. ASG's own line for this is that selling to symptoms is not selling to the problem.

How a sales team builds and uses a PIC

A PIC is built by the team, in a working session, and used by every rep on every discovery call. A first version takes a few hours if the people in the room know the customers well.

  1. List the problems. Write the business problems your product solves, in the words a buyer's executive would use. "Missed revenue targets" is a problem. "No dashboard" is a missing feature.
  2. Find two to four root causes per problem. Each one should be something your product or service can change.
  3. Write the impacts. Name what happens to the business when the problem stays: money, risk, people, reputation.
  4. Check the rows with customers. Read them against recent won deals. A row nobody has ever bought for comes out.
  5. Use it before each call. The rep picks the two or three rows that fit this buyer and writes guesses in brackets, to test on the call.

On the call, the chart keeps discovery consistent. Every rep is asking about the same root causes and impacts, so a manager reviewing five deals can compare them. What the buyer confirms becomes Buyer Input Data, the evidence Gap Selling uses to say a deal is real. The chart is a hypothesis; the buyer's words are the proof.

A PIC row on a live deal

This example is illustrative. A vendor of route planning software has this row on its PIC: problem, late deliveries to large accounts; root causes, routes planned by hand each morning and no live traffic data; impacts, service-level penalties and lost renewals.

Before a call with Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm, the rep marks that row and writes a guess: "[penalties cost them about a month's margin on two accounts]". On the call she asks how routes get planned today. The operations lead says a dispatcher builds them on a spreadsheet at 5 a.m. She asks what happens when a route runs late. Two retail customers charged penalties last quarter, he says, and one is now out to tender. The guess in brackets is replaced by his numbers, and the gap between his current state and the one he wants now has a size.

Reps who want to test their PIC rows on a real deal can talk it through with Keenan, our Gap Selling expert, by voice or video on a call, or try the free deal coach.

Where teams get the PIC wrong

Three mistakes show up again and again. The first is writing features as problems, so the chart reads like a product sheet. The second is stopping at the problem column, which gives reps pain with no cause to fix and no cost to size. The third is building it once and never opening it again. A chart that reps do not use before calls is a document, and discovery goes back to each rep's habits.

Related terms

FAQ

What is a problem identification chart in Gap Selling?

A problem identification chart is a reference built once per product that lists the problems you solve, the root causes behind them and the impacts they create. Reps diagnose every deal against it.

Who created the problem identification chart?

A Sales Growth Company, the firm behind Gap Selling, developed the problem identification chart. It publishes a worksheet for building one and also offers to build a team's PIC as a service.

What are the columns of a problem identification chart?

The chart has three columns: the problem, the root causes that create it, and the impacts that follow when it persists. ASG describes root causes as the specific, fixable issues behind the problem.

How is a PIC used on a discovery call?

Before the call the rep picks the rows that fit the buyer and writes guesses to test. On the call the buyer's answers replace the guesses, and those answers become the evidence the deal rests on.

How often should a team update its PIC?

Review it whenever a product, a market or a common deal pattern changes, and at least once or twice a year. Rows that never come up in won deals should come out.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us