All field notes

Question ·

Can you combine two sales methodologies?

You can combine sales methodologies when each does a different job: one selling method plus one qualification framework. When it works, and when it fails.

You can combine two sales methodologies when each does a different job, usually one selling method for the conversation and one qualification framework for the deal. Two methods competing for the same conversation tend to fail.

The short version

Sales methods fall into two broad kinds. Selling methods, such as Challenger, SPIN, Sandler or Command of the Message, shape what a rep says and asks on a call. Qualification frameworks, such as MEDDPICC, BANT or SPICED, define what must be true about a deal before it counts.

A combination that holds up
Two selling methods
  • Two vocabularies for one conversation
  • Managers coach different words
  • Reps fluent in neither
One selling method, one qualification framework
  • Each does a different job
  • One record for the deal
  • Added one at a time

A pairing that holds up takes one of each. Force Management, which owns Command of the Message, describes MEDDIC as "not a selling methodology" and says its power "multiplies when paired with a strong selling methodology like Command of the Message." Winning by Design makes a similar case for SPICED and MEDDIC, saying MEDDIC "explains WHAT needs to happen" while SPICED gives an idea of "HOW to make this happen."

The test is simple: write down the question each method answers. If one answers how to run the call and the other answers whether the deal is real, they can share a team. If both answer how to run the call, they compete.

Pairing two selling methods is where teams get into trouble. Each has its own vocabulary for the same moment in a call, so managers end up coaching different words for one conversation, and reps end up fluent in neither.

When the owner says no

Some methods carry their own qualification, and their owners argue against adding a separate framework. Check the owner's position before you combine.

A Sales Growth Company, which owns Gap Selling, argues against pairing it with seller-focused checklists such as BANT and MEDDIC. Its method qualifies deals through Buyer Input Data: problems, impacts and success measures stated by the buyer. A team on Gap Selling coaches that discipline directly, and Keenan, our Gap Selling expert, works in those terms.

An illustrative example

This example is illustrative. Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm, runs its own sales team selling freight contracts. The team trained on Challenger two years ago and later added MEDDPICC fields to the CRM.

In deal reviews, the two work together. The rep tells the deal in Challenger terms: what the buyer believed before, the insight that shifted it, how it was tailored for the finance lead. The manager then reads the MEDDPICC letters to check what the buyer has confirmed. The insight explains why the buyer is interested. The letters show whether the deal can close.

The trouble started when a new sales leader brought in SPIN training as well. Reps began mixing Implication questions with Challenger's reframe in the same call, and managers coached them against different models. After a quarter, the team kept SPIN's questioning as a discovery skill inside Challenger and dropped it as a separate method.

How to combine two well

  1. Name the job of each. Write one line on what each method does. If both lines describe the same conversation, pick one.
  2. Check the owner's position. Some owners publish how their method pairs, or that it should not.
  3. Add one at a time. Run the first method in deal reviews for a quarter before adding the second.
  4. Use one record. Keep both sets of fields on the same opportunity, so the manager reads them together.

The full playbook for picking a method is in how to choose a sales methodology, and how to roll out a sales methodology covers the first months. The sales methodology guide compares the main options.

Caty, our AI sales expert for MEDDPICC, Challenger and other methods, coaches reps on live deals in the team's own combination, by voice or video on a call. Our page on coaching a team's own methodology explains how. To see it on your deals, talk to us.

FAQ

What is the most common sales methodology combination?

A common combination is a selling method such as Command of the Message or Challenger with a qualification framework such as MEDDPICC. Force Management recommends pairing MEDDIC with a selling methodology.

Can you use MEDDPICC with Gap Selling?

A Sales Growth Company, which owns Gap Selling, argues against pairing it with seller-focused checklists such as BANT and MEDDIC. Gap Selling qualifies deals through Buyer Input Data stated by the buyer.

Is it bad to use two sales methodologies at once?

Using two selling methods at once usually causes confusion, because each has its own vocabulary for the same conversation. One selling method plus one qualification framework tends to work.

How many sales methodologies should a team use?

Most teams do best with one selling method and, at most, one qualification framework. Adding a third tends to dilute both, and training load grows with every vocabulary reps have to keep exact.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us