All field notes

Comparison ·

Challenger vs MEDDIC: how to sell the change and how to qualify the deal

Challenger tells a rep how to sell change to a buyer; MEDDIC tells a team whether the deal is real. How they differ and fit, with one deal run both ways.

Challenger suits teams that need to sell change to buyers who do not yet see the problem. MEDDIC suits teams that need one standard for whether a deal is real. They answer different questions, so many teams run both.

The Challenger Sale, defined

The Challenger Sale is a selling method in which the rep teaches the buyer something new about their business, tailors that insight to each stakeholder and takes control of the sale.

It comes from The Challenger Sale by Matt Dixon and Brent Adamson, published in 2011 from research at CEB, now part of Gartner. Challenger, the company that teaches it today, says its parent company is Richardson. It names three core behaviors, teach, tailor and take control, and adds constructive tension: pushing the buyer to think differently.

The research sorted reps into five profiles, and Challenger reports that nearly 40% of high performers were Challengers, while Relationship Builders produced just 7% of star performers. Its teaching conversation runs in six steps: the warmer, the reframe, rational drowning, emotional impact, a new way, and your solution. A follow-up book, The Challenger Customer (2015), turns to the buyer side. The Challenger Sale book summary covers both.

Challenger is about the conversation. It tells a rep what to say and how to lead.

MEDDIC, defined

MEDDIC is a B2B qualification framework that tests whether a deal is real and winnable on the buyer's own evidence. The letters stand for Metrics, Economic Buyer, Decision Criteria, Decision Process, Identify Pain and Champion.

It was created at PTC in 1996, and MEDDICC.com credits Dick Dunkel, with Jack Napoli. MEDDICC.com defines a Champion as a person with power and influence who acts as an internal seller for you and has a vested interest in your success. Later versions add letters: MEDDICC adds Competition, and MEDDPICC adds Paper Process. Our MEDDPICC vs MEDDIC piece covers the differences, and the MEDDIC page has the six letters in full.

MEDDIC is about the deal. It says what must be true before a team forecasts it, and leaves the conversation to the selling method.

Side by side

What a team decides on Challenger MEDDIC
What it is A selling method A qualification framework
The question it answers How do we get the buyer to change? Is this deal real, and can we win it?
Who uses it most Reps, in buyer conversations Reps and managers, in deal reviews and forecasts
What the rep prepares An insight backed by data, tailored per stakeholder Evidence for each letter, with who said it
Where it shows up The first meetings and the business case The CRM, the deal review and the forecast call
What managers coach Did the insight surprise the buyer? Was it tailored? Which letters are confirmed and which are guesses?
Main risk Lecturing a buyer who knows their business better A form filled with guesses
Where it comes from Dixon and Adamson, CEB, 2011 PTC, 1996

The table makes the main point: these are different kinds of tool. Choosing between them is a little like choosing between a script and a checklist. Most teams that use both let Challenger shape the conversation and MEDDIC check what the conversation produced.

How the two fit on one deal

Challenger and MEDDIC fit because each Challenger step tends to produce evidence for a MEDDIC letter. The reframe surfaces a problem the buyer had missed, which becomes Identify Pain. Rational drowning puts numbers on it, which is the start of Metrics. Tailoring the insight for the person who signs helps reach the Economic Buyer.

Where Challenger feeds each MEDDIC letter
One deal, qualified with MEDDIC
  1. Identify PainThe reframe names a problem the buyer missed
  2. MetricsRational drowning puts a number on it
  3. ChampionThe Mobilizer who pushes for change
  4. Economic BuyerA tailored version of the insight
  5. Decision CriteriaShaped by the new way
  6. Decision ProcessTake control: dates and commitments
One deal, qualified with MEDDIC
  1. Identify PainThe reframe names a problem the buyer missed
  2. MetricsRational drowning puts a number on it
  3. ChampionThe Mobilizer who pushes for change
  4. Economic BuyerA tailored version of the insight
  5. Decision CriteriaShaped by the new way
  6. Decision ProcessTake control: dates and commitments

The Challenger Customer adds a buyer-side idea: find the stakeholders who push for change inside the account, which the authors call Mobilizers. That maps closely to MEDDIC's Champion. Taking control, with dates and commitments, fills in the Decision Process. And a buyer who accepts a new way of seeing the problem often rewrites the Decision Criteria around it.

One deal, run through both

This example is illustrative. A rep is selling warehouse slotting software to Arrowmere, a 600-person logistics firm. The first meeting is with the head of warehouse operations.

The Challenger conversation. The rep opens with a warmer about pick errors in warehouses that have grown fast, then the reframe: "Most operations teams put mis-picks down to staff turnover. In similar warehouses, the bigger cause is slotting rules that were set years ago and never revisited." The head of operations had blamed turnover. The rep backs it with numbers from similar sites (rational drowning), then asks how many returns last quarter were wrong-item returns (emotional impact, made personal). She does not know, but says her team handles complaints every day.

The rep describes what a warehouse with current slotting looks like (a new way) and asks to analyze a month of Arrowmere's pick data before showing anything (your solution comes later).

The MEDDIC review. Two weeks later, the rep's manager runs a deal review on the same deal, letter by letter.

  • Identify Pain: confirmed. The head of operations said wrong-item returns drive daily complaints, and the pick data showed them clustered in the oldest aisles.
  • Metrics: partly confirmed. She agreed the measure is wrong-item returns per thousand orders, and finance is pulling the current figure.
  • Economic Buyer: identified, not met. The operations director signs anything over her budget.
  • Decision Criteria: unknown. Nobody has said what options will be compared on.
  • Decision Process: unknown beyond "the director decides".
  • Champion: being tested. She shared the pick data, which cost her effort. The next test is the meeting with the director.

The Challenger conversation got the deal started and produced the pain and the start of a metric. The MEDDIC review showed what is still missing: the criteria, the process and the Economic Buyer. The manager's question is about the next call: "What version of the insight will the operations director hear, and what will you ask him to commit to?"

Rolling out both without confusing reps

Most teams that run both add them one at a time. The order depends on the problem, but the rollout looks similar either way.

  1. Pick the main method for conversations. If it is Challenger, build two or three insights for your most common buyer and test them on real calls first.
  2. Write what "confirmed" means for each MEDDIC letter. One line per letter, in buyer evidence, so reps and managers mean the same thing.
  3. Map Challenger steps to the letters they feed. The reframe and rational drowning feed Identify Pain and Metrics; tailoring feeds the Economic Buyer.
  4. Keep the review in one vocabulary. Deal reviews use the MEDDIC letters. Call preparation uses the Challenger steps.
  5. Review a few deals a week. Look for letters filled from the rep's insight with no buyer quote behind them.

Which fits which team

  • Buyers say things are fine, and deals end in no decision. Start with Challenger. MEDDIC will only confirm that the deals lack pain.
  • The forecast is unreliable and deals slip at the end. Start with MEDDIC. It gives managers one standard for calling a deal real.
  • Complex deals with many stakeholders. Use both. Challenger's tailoring helps across the buying group, and MEDDIC checks that the right people are in it.
  • Short, transactional sales. Neither fits fully. A full Challenger teaching pitch and six letters of evidence are a lot of work for a small deal.

Where teams go wrong

  • MEDDIC used as a conversation script. Reps ask "Who is your Economic Buyer?" on a first call. MEDDIC tells you what to find out, and a selling method tells you how to ask.
  • Challenger with no qualification. A buyer who loved the insight is counted as a qualified deal. A good meeting is not a Champion or a budget.
  • Letters filled from the insight. The rep writes the pain from the reframe, in the rep's words. A letter is confirmed only when the buyer says it.
  • Two vocabularies in one review. The manager asks about the reframe and the Champion in the same breath, and the rep hears two methods. Use MEDDIC for the review and Challenger for planning the next conversation.

Coaching both on live deals

The two methods are coached in different places. MEDDIC is coached in the deal review, letter by letter, with one question: "What did the buyer say, and who said it?" Challenger is coached in call reviews and before meetings: "What will the buyer believe after this call that they did not believe before?"

Before the next meeting, a rep can talk the deal through with Caty, our AI sales expert for MEDDIC, Challenger and other methods, by voice or video on a call. She can ask for the evidence behind each letter and help plan the tailored version of the insight for the Economic Buyer. The sales methodology guide shows how teams pair a selling method with a qualification framework, and our page on coaching your team's method on live deals explains how the coaching works.

FAQ

What is the difference between Challenger and MEDDIC?

Challenger is a selling method that tells reps how to teach, tailor and take control in buyer conversations, while MEDDIC is a qualification framework that tests whether a deal is real on the buyer's evidence.

Can you use Challenger and MEDDIC together?

Challenger and MEDDIC work well together because they answer different questions. Challenger shapes the conversation, and MEDDIC checks what the conversation produced, letter by letter, in the deal review.

Is MEDDIC a sales methodology?

MEDDIC is a qualification framework more than a selling method. It defines what must be true about a deal and leaves how to run the conversation to a selling method such as Challenger or SPIN.

Which MEDDIC letter does Challenger help most?

Challenger helps most with Identify Pain and Metrics, because the reframe surfaces a problem the buyer missed and rational drowning puts numbers on it. Its Mobilizer idea also helps find a Champion.

Should a new team start with Challenger or MEDDIC?

A team with an unreliable forecast should usually start with MEDDIC, and a team losing deals to no decision should start with Challenger. Many teams add the second once the first is in use.

Put an expert on your deals.

Talk to Keenan about a live deal for free, or talk to us about experts for your team, your product or your coaching business.

Talk to us